On 11 December 2018, following the death of 111-year-old Tora Kosugi, he became the oldest living person in Niigata Prefecture. He was less than a month younger than her.
On 20 January 2019, following the death of 113-year-old Masazo Nonaka of Hokkaido, Japan, he became the oldest living man in Japan, and a candidate for the title of the world’s oldest living man, at the age of 111 years, 321 days. On 11 February 2020, Watanabe was recognized as the world’s oldest living man by Guinness World Records, eleven days before his passing.
However, several men claimed to be older than Watanabe (including Gustav Gerneth of Germany), none of the claims were officially validated at the time. Subsequently, after his death, it was determined that several men were probably older than him. In August 2020, Domingo Villa Avisencio (of Mexico) was validated by the Latin American Supercentenarians (LAS), he was more than six months older than Watanabe.
In 2022, the LAS discovered how Tomas Pinales Figuereo (of Dominican Republic), who outlived Watanabe, was almost a year older than him. His age was officially validated in 2025, proving Watanabe was never the World’s Oldest Living Man.
Upon his own passing, Issaku Tomoe succeeded him as the Oldest Living Man in Japan.